An ongoing legal dispute between Amyl And The Sniffers vocalist Amy Taylor and US photographer Jamie Nelson has officially come to an end, with both parties choosing to settle. The parties walk away without any money changing hands (other than to the lawyers) but with Nelson given the right to continue to sell prints (digital or physical) of the photographs in question under an agreed covenant not to sue.
The legal dispute stretches back over a year, with Nelson having sold fine art prints of photographs taken of Taylor for a July 2025 issue of Vogue Portugal.
It was alleged that Nelson made contact with Taylor in the hopes of obtaining permission to sell the images as art prints, but was told by the band’s manager that she did not have license or permission to do so.
Despite this, a lawsuit filed by Taylor in December claimed that the images were offered and promoted on Nelson’s website and social platforms regardless, with the photographer allegedly refusing to comply with requests to remove all images from her website and social media accounts.
Nelson denied this, instead having claimed that she had received “responses [that] escalated in a way that [she] experienced as harassment," and having filed a restraining order prior to Taylor's lawsuit.
In February, Nelson filed a counterclaim against Taylor for copyright infringement, and expanded her lawsuit to include "the band entity, Amyl and the Sniffers, and John Angus Stewart of PHC Films, Amy Taylor’s husband, who I contend published defamatory and untrue statements alongside one of my copyrighted images." The action against Stewart and PHC Films was later dropped by Nelson's legal counsel when the counterclaims were amended in June.
In March, Nelson's appeal for a restraining order was declined by a Los Angeles Superior Court judge.
In September, the federal claims were heard, with the judge dismissing with prejudice the Amyl and the Sniffers singer’s claim that Jamie Nelson was confusing the public into believing Taylor had officially endorsed, partnered with, or sponsored the commercial merchandise, recognising the photographs as “expressive artistic works".
Three other points of law remained, including Taylor’s claim that Nelson illegally used her face, name and celebrity status to drive traffic and commercial sales without a valid commercial model release, that both sides had an unwritten understanding (or implied licence) that the photoshoot was strictly for an editorial feature in Vogue Portugal and that Nelson misappropriated Taylor’s name and likeness.
With legal bills mounting, on October 28 the two parties reached an agreement, filing a Joint Stipulation of Dismissal in federal court the following day. The agreement grants Nelson an irrevocable covenant not to sue for print sales on standard mediums, provided Nelson does not use Taylor's name or likeness to advertise other products or services, and does not state or imply that Taylor endorsed the prints or approved the sales.
Both parties also agreed to cover their own legal expenses for actions to date, with no money changing hands as a result of the settlement. Had the case proceeded to trial, it would have created a legal precedent regarding the extent of rights a photographer holds over the images they take, regardless of the subject.
"This case was never just about my photographs," Nelson said in a statement offered to the media. "It was about First Amendment rights, freedom of artistic expression, and the fundamental right of an artist to create, exhibit, and sell their original work without intimidation.
"I fought to defend those principles, not just for myself, but for every independent artist who has ever been pressured into silence."
"I am proud that I stood up for myself, proud of the work I made, and grateful to everyone who supported me through this process," she added. "I hope the next photographer who finds themselves in a similar position knows that their work is worth defending.
“Art is worth defending. And artistic freedom is worth fighting for. For me, that is the victory.”
Amyl and the Sniffers’ manager Simone Ubaldi provided a statement to The Music.
“What Jamie Nelson was fighting for, in our view, was the right to exploit Amy Taylor’s name, face and fame for staggering profit. All we were fighting for was Amy’s right to say no. But frankly, this is not worth our time, our money or our attention anymore.”
“On 28 October, we reached a mutual settlement with Jamie Nelson where both cases were dismissed and no money changed hands. Jamie can continue selling the Vogue Portugal photos of Amy for millions of dollars, the copyright is hers. We wish her the absolute best with that, and we hope other people learn from our mistakes.”
Nelson disputes the characterization of sales figures, noting that estimates published in the media do not reflect actual print sales or revenue.
This piece of content has been assisted by the Australian Government through Music Australia and Creative Australia, its arts funding and advisory body










