Skip to main content

industry > News

Uncovered: Tax Millions Wasted On Classical Music

Melba Records, cashed up with little to sell.
Apr 3rd 2012 | 6:58pm | Scott Fitzsimons
Contemporary music stakeholders are outraged that classical music label Melba received $750,000 to release three albums last year.

As reported in The Australian today, the highly regarded Melbourne-based Melba Recordings has been receiving financial grants of up to $5 million from the government since 2004.

The huge amount of money is seen by contemporary music lobbyists as evidence of a disparity of funding between the classical arts and the rest of the arts and music scene, especially given the smaller audience for the 'classics'.

According to the annual report, last year Melba released three albums. During the year they earned $750,000 in government funds and $275,980 in “patron income” while CD sales (including back catalogue) amounted to $18,000.

Melba's current ambassadors include the likes of Baz Luhrmann, Dame Elisabeth Murdoch, Sir James Wolfensohn and Sir Gustav Nossal.

Today, in an email leaked to The Australian, Musica Viva's artistic director Carl Vine claims that Melba had managed to exclude itself from the peer-review process of Government funding.

He cited labels like ABC Classics, which released 23 records last year, and independent labels like Tall Poppies and Move who dsitribute up to ten releases a year without – or with little – funding.

Outside of the classical realm, contemporary music stakeholders are shocked at the amount of money offered to the classical genre. Today music lobby group SLAM [Save Live Australia's Music] said they were “outraged” in a statement.

“We are outraged that this amount of funding should be provided to a single organisation outside of the peer review process,” they wrote. “The sheer size of the initial grant provided to Melba Recordings is equal to the entire budget of the music board of the Australia Council.

“We are deeply concerned about how this out-of-round funding came about and call on the Australian Government to do a full investigation into the Australia Council and the role of all the Federal Arts Ministers since 2004.”

They added, “At a time when technology is threatening the livelihood of musicians and election promises to the contemporary music sector remain undelivered, we call on the Australian Government to redirect this funding to urgent contemporary music programs and support.”

An email, currently signed by 111 signatures when Your Daily SPA saw it, will be sent to Federal Arts Minister Simon Crean's office.

Your Daily SPA contacted Melba for comment today, but CEO Maria Vandamme was unable to comment in time for deadline. When asking for a media contact, the receptionist assured us that they were a “very small organisation”.

Vandamme told The Australian that Melba had “been denied the possibility of peer assessment because there is no program at the Australia Council to support our work.”

In 2004, when Melba first received the funding ArtsHub ran an article claiming that not only had Vandamme bypassed the Australia Council, but with the aid of “very influential friends” went above the Arts Minister to then-Treasurer Peter Costello.

Federal Minister Crean declined to comment to Your Daily SPA today and is believed to be reviewing Government funding for the promised National Cultural Policy, for which submissions closed last October.


Poster IT

Connect with The Music

Subscribe to Daily Newsletter


<span>Bernard Fanning</span><br />Taronga Zoo

Bernard Fanning
Taronga Zoo

<span>FKA Twigs</span><br />170 Russell

FKA Twigs
170 Russell

<span>The Kooks</span><br />Sidney Myer Music Bowl

The Kooks
Sidney Myer Music Bowl

<span>Nas</span><br />Forum Theatre

Forum Theatre

<span>Sugar Mountain 2015</span><br />

Sugar Mountain 2015

<span>Kim Churchill</span><br />Oxford Art Factory

Kim Churchill
Oxford Art Factory

<span>Nightmares On Wax</span><br />Aurora Spiegeltent

Nightmares On Wax
Aurora Spiegeltent

<span>Roger Knox</span><br />Aurora Spiegeltent

Roger Knox
Aurora Spiegeltent

<span>Ed Kuepper</span><br />City Recital Hall

Ed Kuepper
City Recital Hall

this week's magazine

Digital Version
A Festival Called PANAMA Airlie Beach Music Festival Australasian Worldwide Music Expo Beyond The Valley Big Sky Blues & Roots Festival BIGSOUND Bleach Festival Blue Mountains Music Festival Blues At Bridgetown Bluesfest Breakfest Brisbane Festival Brunswick Music Festival Bruthen Blues & Arts Festival Caloundra Music Festival Campfire Festival CMC Rocks The Hunter CoLAB Deni Ute Muster Dungog Festival Earth Frequency Festival El Grande Festival Fairbridge Folk Festival Falls Festival Falls Festival Falls Festival Farmer & The Owl Festival Of The Sun Follow The Sun Festival Future Music Festival Future Music Festival Future Music Festival Future Music Festival Future Music Festival Golden Plains Gorgeous Festival Great Southern Blues Festival Groovin The Moo Groovin The Moo Groovin The Moo Groovin The Moo Groovin The Moo Groovin The Moo Gympie Music Muster HyperFest JamGrass Music Festival Jungle Love Music & Arts Festival Just For Laughs Kyneton Music Festival Let Them Eat Cake Listen Out Listen Out Listen Out Listen Out Lost Paradise Melbourne Music Week Meredith Music Festival Mitchell Creek Rock 'n' Blues MOFO Mountain Sounds Mullum Music Festival Nannup Music Festival National Folk Festival Newtown Festival Noosa Jazz Festival NYE On The Hill Origin NYE Originals Music Festival Out On The Weekend Outlet Music Festival OutsideIn Paradise Music Festival Party In The Paddock Perth Festival Poison City Weekender Port Fairy Folk Festival Queenscliff Music Festival Rainbow Serpent Festival Riverboats Music Festival Rottofest Saltwater Freshwater Festival Secret Garden Festival Soulfest Soulfest Soulfest Soundwave Soundwave Soundwave Soundwave Southbound Splendour In The Grass St Jerome's Laneway Festival St Jerome's Laneway Festival St Jerome's Laneway Festival St Jerome's Laneway Festival St Jerome's Laneway Festival Stereosonic Stereosonic Stereosonic Stereosonic Stereosonic Strawberry Fields Subsonic Sugar Mountain Festival Sydney Country Music Festival Sydney Festival Sydney Fringe Festival Tamworth Country Music Festival The Blurst Of Times Festival The Hills Are Alive The WA Circus Festival Toowoomba Carnival Of Flowers UNIFY: A Heavy Music Gathering Urban Country Music Festival Valley Fiesta Vanfest WAM Festival West Coast Blues & Roots Festival WOMAdelaide Wonderland Woodford Folk Festival Yours And Owls

The Music Store

Australasian Music Industry Directory
The ultimate print sourcebook for all the contacts…
Jun 18th 2014
Arts Advertising Packages
The Music Arts Packages provide promotion in The Music…
Jun 18th 2014
Indie Band Advertising Packages
The Music Indie Band Packages provide promotion in…
Jun 18th 2014
Galleon Krueger for Sale
Galleon Krueger Bass Amplifier. 1001RB As new, current…
Jul 12th 2014
Jazz guitarists wanted for weekend jams.
We are a bass and drums unit rehearsing in St Peters…
Jul 12th 2014
Premier Sydney Punk/Rock Band seeks Drummer
One of Sydneys Premier Punk Rock Bands seeks energetic…
Jun 18th 2014