The One I Love

Ethan (Mark Duplass) and Sophie (Elizabeth Moss) are a married couple who are on shaky ground and in danger of falling out of love completely. Their therapist (Ted Danson) suggests they spend a weekend away together in a picturesque holiday house to reconnect. Their weekend is quickly derailed when they realise the guesthouse has some strange inhabitants; an alternate Ethan and Sophie.

Ethan’s alternate is charismatic, affable and just generally lighter. Sophie’s alternate is more Stepford-y. The real Ethan and Sophie spend time with their partner’s alternates, causing them to question aspects of their relationship, themselves and each other.

Duplass and Moss’ characters both have their faults but we still want the best for them, which, ultimately, is happiness together. Despite the surreal nature of the film’s plot, these characters demonstrate the very real struggles of a fading relationship.

If you like other Duplass films, especially Safety Not Guaranteed, you’ll probably enjoy this one too. It’s an impressive feature directorial debut by Charlie McDowell, balancing humour and suspense masterfully. If you suspend reality for the duration of the film, you’ll enjoy the ride. If you’re going to be a stick in the mud and get caught up in implausibility, this might not be for you.